Stay tuned with CashEssentials news ! - beyond payments
By subscribing, you accept our Privacy Policy.

Libra coin – Hype or Game-changer?

Categories : Cash is a symbol of national sovereignty, Uncategorized
July 1, 2019
Tags : Central Bank, Innovation, Unbanked
Does Facebook's global d(en)omination herald a new worldwide form of WeChat, the Global Bank of Facebook or virtual nation state?
Frances Rice

This post is also available in: Spanish

The Whatsapp for payments?
“Libra is for everyone.
Moving money around the world should be
as easy and cheap as sending a text message.”
Libra White Paper

Libra coin, facebook, man holding money and paper billimage © CashEssentials

In the media frenzy around Libra, dubbed ‘a simple global digital currency for all’, we take a look at some of the facts and opinion amid all the noise. Is a global payments industry apocalypse, or worse, upon us? Or is Facebook’s latest brainchild just an idealistic vision facing multiple future hurdles?


What’s Libra?
On 18 June 2019, Facebook announced its plan to launch Libra, a “stablecoin”, built on a tailored version of blockchain technology and designed to let people shop and make low-fee money transfers globally. Like Facebook’s previous game-changing initiatives that have transformed the way people interact across the globe, Libra is another bold idea aimed at the masses and capturing attention at the top. Tapping into a potential and growing audience of some 2.4 billion Facebook users (almost twice the population of China or India), Libra aims to be the first global peer-to-peer payments network. It also aims to serve the 1.6 billion people in the world who lack easy access to traditional banking. The new currency is tipped to launch in the first half of 2020.

Who’s behind the currency?
Facebook is behind but not fully in control of Libra. The currency will operate under the Libra Association, a non-profit organisation registered in Geneva, that initially includes 28 mostly private sector partners. Among them are established names like Mastercard, Visa and Vodafone. Others include eBay and PayPal, newer companies such as Spotify and Uber and venture capital firms like Andreessen Horowitz. Notably absent are the large commercial banks, government entities and other large tech companies. In theory, each partner will hold a 1% share among 100 target investors (by the launch date), and each must invest at least USD 10 million in the venture.

Who’s the competition?
Potentially, any traditional and existing payment system and the other “disruptor” currencies, including bitcoin and altcoin, that have emerged in recent years. Yet Libra has some distinct differences. As a ‘stablecoin’ pegged to a basket of different currencies (US dollar (USD), British Pound (GBP), Euro (EUR), Swiss Franc (CHF), and the Japanese Yen (JPY)), Libra will be backed by “real” government-backed assets from central banks, making it less volatile. But the very basis of this stability is already attracting scrutiny from national and global regulators. And the centralised structure of the Facebook Association is inevitably leading to speculation about its possible ambitions to be a power-hungry pseudo centralised global bank, or even to challenge the status quo of nation states.

Could Libra really disrupt the global payments system?
Some fear that the Libra system, if widely adopted, could shake the global economy and rival national banks. Chris Hughes, a Facebook co-founder has warned of the dangers: “This currency would insert a powerful new corporate layer of monetary control between central banks and individuals,” he writes in the Financial Times.

Christine Lagarde, Managing Director and Chairman of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has previously warned about the dangers of potential disruptors using distributed ledger technology: “We don’t want innovation that would shake the system so much that we would lose the stability that is needed.”

French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire sent a letter to officials from the G7 and International Monetary Fund warning that Libra must not become a “sovereign currency,” while Markus Ferber, a German member of the European Parliament, warned that Facebook could become a “shadow bank” and said regulators should be vigilant.

An article about the Libra initiative in the Financial Times exposed an added dimension from the US perspective, quoting Congresswoman Maxine Waters, who said: “It’s not clear who those regulators will be, because the US does not have a regulatory framework for cryptocurrency.”

Nonetheless, if Facebook chiefs were hoping the company would be able to operate without the kind of strict international regulation encountered by banks and other payments companies, they may be in for a surprise. Both the Financial Stability Board (FSB), an international body that monitors and makes recommendations about the global financial system, and the Financial Conduct Authority (FSA) in the UK, have issued warnings. Other commentators have dismissed the scaremongering, emphasising the resilience of central banks.

What are central banks and key regulators saying?

The main concerns for regulators include how Facebook would be able to ensure anti-money laundering measures while protecting users’ data privacy. Global central bankers have largely refrained from regulating digital currencies, concluding that they were too small to pose a risk to the financial system. With Facebook’s new initiative, this position could change. The Basel-based Bank for International Settlements (BIS), an umbrella group for central banks, has called for greater political coordination to deal with the entry into finance of major tech firms like Facebook.

Thomas Moser, an alternate member of the Swiss National Bank’s governing board was more upbeat: “I think it’s an interesting development and I’m pretty relaxed about it. They have clearly indicated that they are willing to play according to the rules, they have been contacting the regulators.”

Speaking about the new economy that’s emerging due to technology, Governor of the Bank of England, Marc Carney, was also upbeat about Facebook’s plans: “Libra may substantially improve financial inclusion and dramatically lower the costs of domestic and cross border payments”. Noting the imperative of transforming payments in general, he also stressed that standards and regulations for innovations such as Libra must be adopted in advance of any launch.

Other European central banks have expressed caution. According to Reuters, several central banks have requested more details on the project and France is using its year-long presidency of the Group of Seven nations (G7) to set up a working group to evaluate the risks of currencies like Libra.

This post is also available in: Spanish