The ATM Paradox: More Cash, Fewer ATMs
The paperSee Banknote paper. More reveals a critical global trend: while cash in circulationThe value (or number of units) of the banknotes and coins in circulation within an economy. Cash in circulation is included in the M1 monetary aggregate and comprises only the banknotes and coins in circulation outside the Monetary Financial Institutions (MFI), as stated in the consolidated balance sheet of the MFIs, which means that the cash issued and held by the MFIs has been subtracted (“cash reserves”). Cash in circulation does not include the balance of the central bank’s own banknot... More continues to grow (outpacing GDP in many economies), ATM networks are shrinking at unprecedented rates. In Europe, ATM numbers have declined by up to 12% annually in some countries, with similar patterns other regions. This decline is not driven by reduced demand for cashMoney in physical form such as banknotes and coins. More but by the unsustainability of current ATM business models, particularly the ATM interchange feeA fee paid between banks for the acceptance of card-based transactions. For instance, a merchant’s bank (acquiring bank) will pay an interchange fee to the cardholder’s bank (issuing bank) when the latter makes a transaction. This is also the case when a cardholder uses an ATM: the cardholder’s bank pays a fee to the ATM operator. More system—the fees banks and operators charge each other for cross-network transactions.
“ATMs are the backbone of cash infrastructure, yet their decline threatens financial inclusionA process by which individuals and businesses can access appropriate, affordable, and timely financial products and services. These include banking, loan, equity, and insurance products. While it is recognised that not all individuals need or want financial services, the goal of financial inclusion is to remove all barriers, both supply side and demand side. Supply side barriers stem from financial institutions themselves. They often indicate poor financial infrastructure, and include lack of ne... More, economic resilience, and the basic rights of those who rely on cash,” said Guillaume Lepecq, co-founder of CashEssentials. “Without intervention, we risk creating ‘cash deserts’—areas where vulnerable populations, including the elderly, low-income individuals, and those in remote regions, lose access to cash which is essential for their daily lives.”
Key Findings: A System Under Pressure
- Interchange fees are failing ATM operators: fees set by card schemes (e.g., Visa, Mastercard) often do not cover operational costs, forcing ATM operators to close unprofitable machines. In some markets, fees have remained stagnant for 10–15 years, despite inflation and rising security costs.
- Lack of transparency: fee structures are opaque, with no input from ATM operators in their determination, leading to arbitrary pricing that undermines viability.
- Market concentration: a handful of card schemes dominate fee-setting, creating anti-competitive pressures that disproportionately harm independent ATM deployers (IADs).
- Alternatives fall short: cash withdrawals at retail stores or bank branches cannot replace ATMs due to scalability, security, and accessibility issues. In the Eurozone, 79% of cash withdrawals still occur at ATMs.
Global Case Studies: Lessons for Reform
The report highlights successful models from countries that have addressed ATM sustainability:
- India: Regulated fee increases and “unified banking centers” combining cash and digital services have driven 10–15% annual ATM growth.
- Netherlands (Geldmaat): Banks pooled their ATM estates into a joint venture, ensuring equitable cost-sharing and nationwide coverage.
- Poland: Independent cost studies led to fee increases, stabilizing the ATM market.
Policy Recommendations: A Call to Action
To reverseThe back of the banknote or coin. See Obverse. More the decline, CashEssentials urges policymakers, regulators, and industry stakeholders to adopt a multi-pronged approach:
- Reform Interchange Fees:
- Mandate transparency in fee-setting processes.
- Tie fees to actual costs (e.g. cash logisticsThe term originates from military language and refers to the movement and provisioning of troops at war. In today’s business vocabulary, it refers to the management in particular, the transportation, storage and distribution of finished goods. More, maintenance) via independent cost studies.
- Introduce variable fee components to reflect cash-handling expenses.
- Public Sector Intervention:
- Subsidize ATMs in underserved areas (e.g. rural, low-income neighbourhoods).
- Enforce universal service obligations requiring banks to maintain minimum ATM density.
- Encourage Competition:
- Deregulate non-bank ATM operators (e.g., fintechs, retailers) to diversify the market.
- Promote white-label ATMs and shared branding to reduce costs.
- Strengthen Resilience:
- Integrate ATMs into national emergency plans (e.g., backup power, mobile ATMs for crises).
- Monitor “cash deserts” via centralized data collection (e.g., real-time ATM mapping).
- Legislative Safeguards:
- Protect existing ATMs by requiring banks to justify closures.
- Set minimum density standards (e.g., maximum travel time to the nearest ATM).
- Innovation and Education:
- Expand cardless withdrawals and multi-function ATMs (e.g., bill payments, digital wallet top-ups).
- Educate consumers on fee transparency and alternatives like cashbackA service whereby the customer pays electronically a higher amount to a retailer than the value of the purchase for goods and/or services and receives the difference in cash. It is also a reward system associated with credit card usage, whereby the consumer receives a percentage of the amount spent on the credit card. More.
A Fixable Market Failure
Cash remains a critical tool for financial inclusion, serving as a privacy-preserving, crisis-resistant, and universally accessible payment methodSee Payment instrument. More. The erosion of ATM networks disproportionately affects:
- Vulnerable populations (elderly, unbanked, low-income individuals).
- Small businesses that rely on cash transactions.
- Economic resilience during crises (e.g., power outages, cyberattacks).
“The decline of ATMs is not inevitable—it’s a fixable market failure,” said Matt Sykes, co-author of the report. “With the right policies, we can ensure that cash remains accessible to everyone, everywhere, while fostering innovation in digital payments. The goal is not to choose between cash and digital, but to build a balanced, inclusive paymentA transfer of funds which discharges an obligation on the part of a payer vis-à-vis a payee. More ecosystem.”
Next Steps
CashEssentials calls on central banks, regulators, and industry leaders to:
- Convene a task force to develop national ATM strategies.
- Pilot reforms in high-risk areas (e.g. rural regions, low-income urban centers).
- Monitor and adapt policies based on evolving technology and consumer needs.
Documents